Difference Between American Football and Rugby

American football and rugby may look similar, but their rules are very different. Compare players, passing, scoring, equipment, and gameplay in this simple guide.

Watch American football and rugby for the first time, the similarities are difficult to miss. Players carry an oval-shaped ball, defenders bring opponents to the ground, and both teams spend much of the game fighting for territory.

That is usually where the similarities end. Stay with either game for a few minutes, and they begin to tell completely different stories. American football moves through carefully planned plays, with teams regularly stopping and resetting. Rugby keeps the action moving, forcing players to react to what is happening around them. Even something as simple as passing the ball works differently, and that one difference changes almost everything else.

Read more: What Is the NFL: A Beginner’s Guide

How Is the Ball Moved in Each Sport?

An American football offense gets four downs to gain at least 10 yards. The quarterback can hand the ball to a runner or throw a forward pass, allowing one successful play to move the team a huge distance down the field.

Rugby does not give teams four attempts to reach a fixed distance. Players can carry the ball forward and kick it forward, but passes with the hands must go backwards or sideways. After a tackle, play can continue through another phase, meaning the team has to keep finding ways through the defence without simply resetting after every attempt. That difference in movement also explains why the players themselves have very different responsibilities.

Do American Football and Rugby Have the Same Players?

American football has 11 players from each team on the field at a time, while rugby union has 15. But the bigger difference is what those players are expected to do. American football is highly specialised. Offensive and defensive units have different players, while quarterbacks, receivers, running backs, and linemen each perform specific roles.

Rugby players have specialised positions too, but the same 15 players generally have to attack and defend as possession changes. A player involved in carrying the ball one moment may be making a tackle shortly afterwards. And when those tackles start flying in, perhaps the easiest difference to spot is what everyone is wearing.

Also read: What Is VAR And How Does It Work in Football?

Why Does American Football Use More Protective Equipment?

NFL players wear helmets, shoulder pads, and other protective equipment, giving American football its instantly recognisable appearance. Rugby players generally compete without hard helmets or large shoulder pads, although some may wear lighter protective equipment.

The sports also handle contact differently. American football’s explosive collisions happen within short individual plays before the action stops. Rugby tackles happen during a more continuous flow, with play often continuing immediately after the ball carrier goes down. Put those differences together and the two sports start looking far less alike.

American Football vs Rugby: The Main Differences

How Does Scoring Work?

The different styles eventually lead towards the same objective: putting points on the board. In American football, reaching the opponent’s end zone with possession scores a touchdown worth six points, followed by an opportunity for additional points. Teams can also kick a field goal for three.

In rugby union, grounding the ball in the opposition’s in-goal area scores a try worth five points, with a successful conversion adding another two. Penalty goals and drop goals can add three points. So while a touchdown and a try might look similar to a newcomer, even the way players complete the score is different.

Which Is Harder: American Football or Rugby?

There really is no simple answer. American football places enormous importance on specialised roles, set plays, and executing a plan within a matter of seconds. Rugby asks players to make decisions while the game continues around them, combining endurance, tackling, passing, and positioning over longer phases. That is why calling one a harder version of the other misses the point. They may share some of the same roots and ideas, but they have evolved into two very different sports.

American football turns the fight for territory into a sequence of carefully planned battles. Rugby allows that battle to keep developing as the players move across the field. And once you understand that difference, you probably will not mistake the two again. Which one do you prefer watching, American football or rugby? Let us know in the comments.

Explore more: Most Successful National Teams in World Cup History